Somebody Has to Do It: Workers in 'Dirty Jobs' Cope With Stigma
总有一些工作，诸如垃圾回收，街道清理，火葬等等，它们被归类于Dirty Jobs的行列中，而且从事这个行业的人员也很少能因为工作得到人们的赞誉，但是，毕竟这些工作还是需要有人去做的，那作为这些行业的HR们，又该如何来激励自己的员工更好工作，同时又改变这种不被大众认可的情况呢? The butcher, the baker and the candlestick maker engage in wholesome, respected, solid lines of work. But the trash collector, the street sweeper and the undertaker are another story. Viewed as unpleasant, menial or just plain strange, theirs are among the kinds of dirty jobs that someone has to do -- and that inspire specific coping strategies by workers and special approaches by management, according to research by Blake Ashforth, professor of management at the W.P. Carey School of Business. In the paper Normalizing Dirty Work: Tactics for Countering Occupational Taint, Ashforth and three other researchers -- Glen E. Kreiner of the University of Cincinnati, Mark A. Clark of American University and Mel Fugate of Southern Methodist University -- interviewed managers and surveyed workers from
18 lines of dirty work. They list three kinds of taint -- physical, social and moral -- and say dirty work can range from relatively low-prestige (prostitutes) to relatively high-prestige fields (personal-injury lawyers) of endeavor. Curiously, even though people may view some forms of dirty work as not only necessary but even noble and heroic [e.g., firefighting, social services counseling], they tend to remain psychologically distanced from the work, glad that others are doing it, the study states. The degree and/or breadth of the taint associated with the job is such that people desire to separate themselves from the work -- despite perhaps feeling somewhat indebted to the noble-but-dirty worker. 1.) Occupational ideologies. For example, the unpleasant task of dogcatchers is made more acceptable when they focus on the virtue of preventing bites and rabies. 2.) Social buffers. In a positive sense, workers join a social network to share experiences and coping tactics; in a negative sense, high-class call girls look down on streetwalkers. 3.) Confronting clients and the public. This includes direct rebuttals (a chauffeur refusing to be treated like a servant by a client), indirect challenges through humor (a lawyer joking about the common tag of being an ambulance chaser) and counter-stereotypical behavior (a car salesman going the extra mile to be honest with customers). 4.) Defensive tactics. A janitor likes working at night because it spares him or her contact with the building occupants. The study says dirty workers are acutely aware of the stigma they carry but that they need some sort of affirmation, or their job performance, commitment and sense of well-being will suffer. An employee's ability to negotiate the stigma -- and a manager's ability to facilitate that process -- is therefore essential to improving important individual and organizational outcomes, states Normalizing Dirty Work. The researchers said 39 of the 54 managers they interviewed said society misunderstands their occupations. Managers try to remedy such misperceptions when they train new workers, help them make sense of what they are doing, teach them how to deal with outsiders' attitudes and provide role models. To the extent that individual normalizing tactics are in fact institutionalized at the group level, it may be largely through the efforts of managers, the study states. Moreover, managers are typically more experienced than frontline workers and may thus serve as knowledgeable informants. Managerial guidance helps dirty workers rationalize what they do, and good managers put workers in a psychological position to individually find ways to feel good about their work. The research findings were echoed in documentary filmmakers Tim Nackashi and David Sampliner's Dirty Work, which was named best documentary feature at the 2004 Atlanta Film Festival and was an official selection at the Sundance Film Festival. The film follows a septic tank pumper who views himself as an anthropologist of sorts, a bull semen collector who takes pride in being a staunch ally of the family farmer and an embalmer who is a self-styled restorative artist. The study by Ashforth and his colleagues cites the examples of an exterminator who elevates his profession by developing an expertise in identifying various types of pests and insects, and that of a manure spreader who speaks of his autonomy and enjoyment of being outdoors. Such occupational recalibration is an essential survival tactic. Reframing infuses the work with positive value and/or negates its negative value, the researchers state. For example, a manager of animal control officers is quoted as follows: I tell all of them you have to find something you really, really like about this job, something that makes you feel good inside, whether it would be placing a dog with some little kid or making some family happy that they found this perfect pet. Because there's a lot of bad aspects to this job. A collection agent's manager makes this statement: A lot of people don't realize that collectors are there to help the customers, not to hassle them or harass them, which is a word I hear a lot. Once the customer finally realized that, 'Hey, we're here to help you get out of your financial difficulty,' their perception changed significantly from bad guy to 'Wow, you guys really are helpful. Thank you.' Although society may fairly or unfairly brand certain occupations as physically, socially, or morally tainted, the study by Ashforth and his colleagues concludes, the managers of such occupations articulated an impressive array of techniques for normalizing the taint. It is through normalizing that occupational members are able to derive pride and identification from jobs that society necessitates but then sanctimoniously disavows. So-called dirty workers and their managers face a constant struggle for validation as they provide essential services everyone depends on.The researchers discovered four types of practices that normalize taint: 管理新知 您可能感兴趣的文章 HR微语—人事管理与人力资源管理的区别 2011-11-30 U.S. Economy Shows Job Growth Strength; Adds 215k Jobs 2013-12-05 Worst Job Growth in Two Years Stuns Analysts 2014-01-11 最近文章 嫖娼被抓不属无故旷工，公司解雇赔4万！（法院判决） 2018年01月15日 如何判断你是否具有HRBP胜任力？
2018年01月15日 阿里为什么不去清华招人？
2018年01月15日 因利益冲突，Facebook COO和Twitter CEO退出迪士尼董事会 2018年01月15日 沪调整城乡居民养老保险有关标准 24日前可就近办理 2018年01月13日 热门文章 嫖娼被抓不属无故旷工，公司解雇赔4万！（法院判决） 2018年01月15日 如何判断你是否具有HRBP胜任力？
2018年01月15日 阿里为什么不去清华招人？
2018年01月15日 2017年度职场出差行程调查，出差最多的居然是他们！！
2018年01月12日 员工在自己QQ空间评论HR经理吃屎，可辞退他吗？
2018年01月11日 扫一扫 加微信【已隐去】 关于沙龙 顾问委员 广告推广 隐私安全 联系我们 申请vip会员 支付方式 市场合作或广告投放 电话：【电话已隐去】 邮件：【邮箱已隐去】 在线QQ【已隐去】 VIP会员 企业VIP会员 机构VIP会员 广告刊例 商务合作 Follow HRSalon